Line 20: Line 20:
* This motion was ruled by the Constitutional Court to require a [[Senate_motion#Constitutional_Vote|constitutional vote]] - it was duly passed by the Senate and ratified by the Throne.
* This motion was ruled by the Constitutional Court to require a [[Senate_motion#Constitutional_Vote|constitutional vote]] - it was duly passed by the Senate and ratified by the Throne.


This motion was judged to represent a considerable shift in power ''from'' individual nations and their generals ''to'' the [[Imperial Military Council]]. As such it required ratification by the Senate on that basis.  
This motion required ratification by the Senate as it was judged to represent a considerable shift in power ''from'' individual nations and their generals ''to'' the [[Imperial Military Council]].
 
In the final process of scrutiny, it was identified that the appointment of the Quartermaster General could fall within the provenance of the Senate rather than the Military Council - due to the appointment method for this Imperial title which allowed for input from both houses. As a result, the motion was ruled unconstitutional - with the recommendation to raise an administrative motion to change the method of appointment of the Quartermaster General - to be by majority vote of the Military Council. If this administrative motion is passed by the [[Imperail Senate]] - then the motion will pass into law.


[[Category: Senate Motion]]
[[Category: Senate Motion]]

Revision as of 20:14, 8 September 2016

To amend the powers of the Quartermaster General.

To include the power to announce to the Senate once each season to which Armies, Navies, Fortifications and/or Spy Networks the Imperial Guerdon will apply that season.

Proposed by Segura, Seconded by Casinea


Overview

  • This motion has constitutional implications
  • The motion requires ratification by The Throne
  • Passed
  • This followed on from a previous motion to amend the powers of the Quartermaster General of the Imperial Armies

Date

  • Summer 380YE

Campaign Outcome

Scrutiny

  • This motion was ruled by the Constitutional Court to require a constitutional vote - it was duly passed by the Senate and ratified by the Throne.

This motion required ratification by the Senate as it was judged to represent a considerable shift in power from individual nations and their generals to the Imperial Military Council.

In the final process of scrutiny, it was identified that the appointment of the Quartermaster General could fall within the provenance of the Senate rather than the Military Council - due to the appointment method for this Imperial title which allowed for input from both houses. As a result, the motion was ruled unconstitutional - with the recommendation to raise an administrative motion to change the method of appointment of the Quartermaster General - to be by majority vote of the Military Council. If this administrative motion is passed by the Imperail Senate - then the motion will pass into law.