Empire
Rules Reminder
You must avoid using gendered nouns when referring to mixed groups. See the Conduct page for more information.
Previous rules reminders

Reallocate an Imperial Wayleave to the Imperial Orcs

No edit summary
Line 8: Line 8:
* This would effectively remove one of the Imperial Wayleaves from the public auction, and make it a national title for the Imperial Orcs.
* This would effectively remove one of the Imperial Wayleaves from the public auction, and make it a national title for the Imperial Orcs.
==Constitution==
==Constitution==
This motion has been failed scrutiny. The Constitutional Court will not permit a national title to be appointed that lasts a single season, the circumstances that make that legal for a Wayleave are unique to wayleaves which are sold by public auction to all citizens. The constitutional court would not permit a title with the power of commission to be appointed for a single season, primarily because it is too burdensome for both the civil service and for citizens to appoint the title that frequently.
This motion has failed scrutiny. The Constitutional Court will not permit a national title to be appointed that lasts a single season, the circumstances that make that legal for a Wayleave are unique to wayleaves which are sold by public auction to all citizens. The constitutional court would not permit a title with the power of commission to be appointed for a single season, primarily because it is too burdensome for both the civil service and for citizens to appoint the title that frequently.


The motion would be constitutional if also changed the title to serve for a year, instead of a single season. As this guidance was not provided before the motion was brought before the Senate, the court have indicated that they will raise an administrative motion on the Friday night of the next summit to request confirmation or rejection by the Imperial Senate on that basis. If this motion is successful then the senator for Hahnmark will need to provide a name for the Imperial title that is created by this motion.
The motion would be constitutional if also changed the title to serve for a year, instead of a single season. As this guidance was not provided before the motion was brought before the Senate, the court have indicated that they will raise an administrative motion on the Friday night of the next summit to request confirmation or rejection by the Imperial Senate on that basis. If this motion is successful then the senator for Hahnmark will need to provide a name for the Imperial title that is created by this motion.
{{Senate Motion}}
{{Senate Motion}}

Revision as of 12:56, 4 September 2018

In recognition of their Loyalty to the Empire, for ceding territory to the Thule as a price for peace, I move that one of the Imperial Wayleaves auctioned via the Bourse instead be assigned to the Imperial Orcs via their well worn paths and traditions.
Proposed by Hahnmark, seconded by Segura.

Overview

Date

  • Summer 382YE

Outcome

  • This would effectively remove one of the Imperial Wayleaves from the public auction, and make it a national title for the Imperial Orcs.

Constitution

This motion has failed scrutiny. The Constitutional Court will not permit a national title to be appointed that lasts a single season, the circumstances that make that legal for a Wayleave are unique to wayleaves which are sold by public auction to all citizens. The constitutional court would not permit a title with the power of commission to be appointed for a single season, primarily because it is too burdensome for both the civil service and for citizens to appoint the title that frequently.

The motion would be constitutional if also changed the title to serve for a year, instead of a single season. As this guidance was not provided before the motion was brought before the Senate, the court have indicated that they will raise an administrative motion on the Friday night of the next summit to request confirmation or rejection by the Imperial Senate on that basis. If this motion is successful then the senator for Hahnmark will need to provide a name for the Imperial title that is created by this motion.

Retrieved from "https://www.profounddecisions.co.uk/mediawiki-public/index.php?title=Reallocate_an_Imperial_Wayleave_to_the_Imperial_Orcs&oldid=68070"